Dowry Death Cases u/s 304-B & 498A: Guidelines

The import of Section 304-B is quite different from 498A. They cannot be held to be mutually inclusive. They deal with two distinct offences. Cruelty is a common factor in both the sections. Under Section 304-B dowry death alone is punishable. Such a death should have occurred within seven years of marriage. In Section 498-A no such period is mentioned. If the case is established, there can be a conviction under both the sections.

Quashing of FIR u/s 482 CrPC

The High Court has powers to quash any proceedings in exercise of its inherent powers when the complaint or even charge sheet does not disclose any offence or when the complaint was frivolous, vexatious or oppressive in nature. Even uncalled for remarks of judges can also be quashed under the Section. To quash a case it must be examined whether a criminal offence is constituted or not at the face of the allegation. Any frivolous, vexatious or oppressive proceeding can be quashed. The quashing of the complaint must be taken at the threshold before evidence is taken in support of the complaint.

Distinction between Culpable Homicide & Murder

The crime of killing a human being by another human being is categorized as Culpable Homicide under Section 299 and as Murder under Section 300 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The Sections separate the most heinous killing from those which are less serious ones in nature. Even though both provisions relating to Culpable Homicide and Murder correspond with each other, the difference in both the offences – Culpable Homicide and Murder - lies in the certainty of death in the latter. In fact the difference is in regard to gravity - the seriousness of the act of crime.If the act of the accused is so dangerous with no possibility of survival for the victim, it is an apt case of Murder. If a person dies out of an intentional act of cutting someone’s head, then there is no chance for his survival. Then that is nothing but Murder. On the other hand, if an act of crime leaves the victim with some chance for escaping death it is a case of Culpable Homicide.