In Gayatri Balasamy v. M/s ISG Novasoft Technologies Limited [2025 INSC 605], a Constitution Bench of five judges of the Supreme Court of India held that courts have a narrow and limited power to modify arbitral awards under Sections 34 and 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (A&C Act), thereby partly departing from its earlier stance in NHAI v. M. Hakeem.
The Power to Set Aside and the Power to Modify are Different Powers
The Court clarified that the power to set aside does not include the power to modify. The power to modify is not a lesser power subsumed in the power to set aside; the two do not come from the same source and are qualitatively different powers under the A&C Act.
Supreme Court’s Earlier Stance
Earlier, in Project Director, NHAI v. M. Hakeem [(2021) 9 SCC 1], the Supreme Court held that Section 34 of the A&C Act does not empower courts to modify an arbitral award. The court’s power was confined to setting the award aside or, under Section 34(4), giving the tribunal an opportunity to cure the defect.
Supreme Court’s Rulings in Gayatri Balasamy
The Court held that a court under Section 34, and the courts in the appellate hierarchy under Section 37, have no general power to modify an award, re-evaluate its merits or rewrite the tribunal’s decision. They may, however, modify it within the following narrow parameters:
- Severability: Where the invalid portion of an award can be cleanly separated from the valid portion, the court may sever it. The Court treated modification and severance as distinct: modification is not permitted under Section 34, but severance of the part of an award that falls foul of Section 34 is permissible. This power is also available to the courts in the appellate hierarchy.
- Error Correction: The court may correct computational, clerical or typographical errors, and other errors of a similar nature, without reappraising the merits.
- Post-Award Interest: The court may modify post-award interest in appropriate circumstances.
- Article 142 Jurisdiction: Only the Supreme Court (not High Courts or District Courts) may use this power to do complete justice in exceptional circumstances, with great care and caution.