When a sub-contractor working under an oral agreement dies at a worksite, the grieving family can claim compensation even if there is no written contract. Under Indian law, oral and implied employment arrangements are legally recognised, and the legal dependants of a deceased worker may have statutory and other legal remedies.
Lack of a Written Contract Does Not Disqualify a Claim
Indian labour laws recognise the actual circumstances of an employment relationship rather than relying exclusively on written documentation. A principal employer, main contractor or site owner cannot automatically escape statutory liability merely by avoiding written agreements or describing a worker as a “sub-contractor.
Under Section 2(26) of the Code on Social Security, 2020, an employee may be engaged directly or through a contractor, and the terms of employment may be express or implied.
To determine whether the family can claim statutory compensation, the competent authority examines the actual nature of the deceased’s working relationship, rather than merely the designation given to the individual.
Sub-Contractor May Qualify as an “Employee”
At many construction sites, a person described as a “sub-contractor” may actually be a skilled worker who is paid on a piece-rate or daily-wage basis and works directly under the instructions and supervision of the main contractor or site management.
If the deceased was engaged to perform work for wages, personally carried out the assigned work and operated within an employment arrangement, the individual may qualify as an employee under the Code on Social Security, 2020, notwithstanding the “sub-contractor” label.
The existence of an independent business, the engagement of other labourers, the provision of machinery, the degree of supervision and the assumption of commercial risks are relevant factors in determining the actual relationship.
Under Section 74 of the Code on Social Security, 2020, an employer is liable to pay compensation where an employee suffers an injury arising out of and in the course of employment, resulting in death or other compensable consequences.
Importantly, Section 85 of the Code of Social Security,2020 deals with contracting. When an employer engages a contractor to execute any work ordinarily forming part of the employer’s trade or business, the employer is liable to pay compensation to an employee engaged in executing that work, subject to the statutory conditions. The principal employer may subsequently seek indemnification from the contractor. The employee’s right to recover compensation from the contractor is also preserved under this provision.
Therefore, depending on the facts, both the main contractor and the principal employer may be legally answerable for compensation arising from a fatal worksite accident.
On Proving an Oral Contract in Court
In the absence of a signed agreement, the legal dependants must establish, through documentary and oral evidence, that the deceased was engaged in the work at the site:
- Financial Records: Bank transfers, UPI payment screenshots, cash vouchers, payment acknowledgements or other records showing payments made by the contractor.
- Digital Footprints: WhatsApp messages, SMS instructions, voice notes, call records and other electronic communications relating to the coordination and supervision of site work.
- Site Records & Witnesses: Gate-entry registers, attendance records, work-allocation registers, CCTV footage and testimonies from co-workers, supervisors or other persons who were present at the site.
Such evidence can help establish the oral employment arrangement, the payment of wages, the nature of the work and the circumstances in which the accident occurred.
Claiming as a True Independent Sub-Contractor
If the deceased genuinely operated an independent business by employing their own team of workers, providing their own machinery, independently undertaking contractual obligations and bearing the commercial risks of profit or loss, the competent authority may classify the individual as an independent contractor rather than an employee.
In such circumstances, the dependants may not automatically qualify for compensation under Chapter VII of the Code on Social Security, 2020, unless the deceased otherwise falls within the statutory definition of an employee covered by that Chapter. However, labourers employed by the sub-contractor may independently qualify for statutory protection.
Civil Suit for Negligence
Even where the deceased was genuinely an independent contractor, the family may have a civil remedy if the death resulted from the negligence or wrongful act of the site owner, principal employer, main contractor or another responsible person. Under Section 1A of the Fatal Accidents Act, 1855, a claim for damages may be brought for the benefit of the statutory beneficiaries where the death resulted from a wrongful act, neglect or default that would have entitled the deceased to maintain an action had death not occurred. Examples may include uninsulated live electrical wires, defective scaffolding, unsafe working platforms or failure to take reasonable safety precautions.
However, the availability of a civil damages claim and a statutory employment compensation claim must be examined carefully. Section 74(7) of the Code contains restrictions on pursuing a civil damages suit and statutory compensation for the same employment injury. The appropriate remedy must therefore be assessed before proceedings are initiated.
Additional Welfare and Insurance Avenues
Beyond direct claims against the contractor or principal employer, families should explore two other important sources of financial relief:
- State Construction Welfare Boards: If the tragedy occurred at a building or construction site and the deceased was an eligible registered member of the Kerala Building and Other Construction Workers Welfare Board, the family should immediately apply for the applicable welfare benefits. The Board’s published schemes include an accidental death benefit of ₹4 lakh, a separate death benefit of ₹50,000 and funeral assistance, subject to the respective eligibility requirements. The Board also provides other benefits, including Santhwanam assistance. The family’s entitlement will depend on the deceased’s membership status, the circumstances of death and the applicable scheme conditions.
- Worksite Insurance Policies: Principal employers and main contractors may have purchased Employees’ Compensation insurance policies or Contractor’s All Risks (CAR) insurance policies. Depending on the policy wording, contractual arrangements, endorsements and exclusions, coverage may extend to workers engaged through contractors or sub-contractors. Families should obtain the relevant insurance policy and verify whether the deceased was covered. A CAR policy should not automatically be treated as providing Employees’ Compensation coverage.
Immediate Action for Legal Heirs
If a family faces such a tragedy, taking prompt action is critical to prevent the loss or destruction of evidence at the worksite:
- Register an FIR and Ensure a Post-Mortem: The family should ensure that the fatal accident is officially reported to the police and that a proper investigation is conducted. A post-mortem examination should be requested where appropriate. The First Information Report (FIR), post-mortem report, inquest records and other police documents can serve as important evidence in subsequent compensation, negligence and insurance proceedings. Families should not accept an informal settlement without first understanding and protecting their legal rights.
- Secure Digital Evidence Immediately: Preserve the deceased’s mobile phone, back up relevant data, save WhatsApp conversations with the contractor, and obtain bank and UPI statements showing previous payments. Photographs, CCTV footage, electronic communications and details of witnesses should also be secured before they disappear.
- Approach the Labour Department and Competent Authority: Consult a local labour lawyer immediately to initiate proceedings before the competent authority appointed under Section 91 of the Code on Social Security, 2020. Under Section 81, compensation payable in respect of an employee whose injury results in death must be deposited with the competent authority, which determines the eligible dependants and distributes the compensation in accordance with the law. Section 82 prescribes the notice and claim requirements, including a general limitation period of two years from the date of death, subject to the statutory exceptions. Families should not delay filing their claims.
- The legal dependants should also approach the Kerala Building and Other Construction Workers Welfare Board, where applicable, and independently pursue any eligible insurance benefits.