Police Reform: The Foundation of Better Governance

Why police reform matters

Police reform is the most basic reform our state and country need. A police force that is professional, accountable and free from improper pressure can help reduce serious crimes such as murder and rape, as well as cyber-crimes. It also improves road safety, because disciplined enforcement and better public trust can cut traffic violations and accident deaths. Above all, it gives every citizen a safe, secure and peaceful life.

The Supreme Court’s seven directions

In Prakash Singh & Others v. Union of India & Others [(2006) 8 SCC 1], the Supreme Court gave its judgment on 22 September 2006 on several aspects of police reform and directed the Union and State Governments to comply. The seven directions are:

  1. State Security Commission: Each State must set up a commission to keep police functioning free from government pressure, lay down broad policy and evaluate police performance.
  2. Selection and tenure of the DGP: The DGP must be chosen from the three senior-most officers empanelled by the UPSC, and must have a minimum tenure of two years.
  3. Minimum tenure for key officers: Police officers on operational duties must be given a minimum tenure of two years. This covers the IG of Zone, DIG of Range, SP in charge of a district and SHO in charge of a police station.
  4. Separation of investigation from law and order: The investigating police must be separated from the law and order police, starting with towns and urban areas with a population of ten lakh or more. The Court said this is to ensure speedy investigation, better expertise and better rapport with the people, while keeping full coordination between the two wings.
  5. Police Establishment Board: This body decides transfers, postings, promotions and other service matters of officers up to the rank of Deputy Superintendent, and recommends on higher ranks.
  6. Police Complaints Authority: Authorities at State and district level inquire into public complaints of serious police misconduct, such as custodial death, grievous hurt and rape in custody.
  7. National Security Commission: This body is meant to select and place the heads of the Central Police Organisations.

The directions on the State Security Commission, the DGP’s selection and tenure, and the Establishment Board are the ones aimed at reducing political interference in policing. The direction on investigation is about separating functions, not about freedom from the Home Minister’s control.

The Kerala High Court on investigation

The Kerala High Court has also spoken on this. In April 2017, a Division Bench of Justice P.R. Ramachandra Menon and Justice Hariprasad, hearing appeals in a 1992 double murder case from Nelliyampathy, noted the sad state of crime investigation in Kerala and asked the government to take concrete action to separate crime investigation from the maintenance of law and order. The Bench also recalled that in Joseph Kuncheria v. State of Kerala (2014 (3) KLT 1), the Court had reminded all concerned that police responsibility does not end with the filing of a final report.

Other Supreme Court rulings on police accountability

  • D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal [(1997) 1 SCC 416]: guidelines to prevent custodial torture and to protect the rights of arrested persons.
  • Lalita Kumari v. Government of U.P. [(2014) 2 SCC 1]: registration of an FIR is mandatory when information discloses a cognizable offence.
  • Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar [(2014) 8 SCC 273]: arrest should not be automatic or routine, and police must record reasons.
  • Paramvir Singh Saini v. Baljit Singh [(2021) 1 SCC 184]: directions for CCTV cameras in police stations to prevent custodial abuse.

What has happened in Kerala

The administrative, practical and financial aspects of separating law and order from crime investigation in the Kerala Police were studied in the K.G. Prem Shankar report of 2016.

The Kerala Police Act, 2011 also contains provisions on separating investigation from law and order. On the ground, change has been slow. Recent steps have focused on how police stations are run.

Kerala has issued an order reorganising the Station House Officer system in 203 police stations, with 274 Inspectors transferred. A police headquarters committee has also studied how to restructure the Inspector-SHO system in law-and-order police stations.

The way forward

  • Implement the Prakash Singh directions fully, in letter and spirit.
  • Create dedicated, trained investigation units with proper forensic and cyber support.
  • Protect fixed tenures for senior officers so that postings are not used as rewards or punishments.
  • Make the Police Complaints Authority strong and independent, so citizens can complain without fear.
  • Publish reports and action-taken updates openly, so the public can see what is being done.

Sadly, none of the police reform reports has been implemented effectively, in Kerala or in India, so far. Justice delayed in investigation is justice denied to victims, and reformed police is the first step to restoring public trust.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *